Rate It

Seen it:    
Not seen it: 
Review: 
 
clear rating

Share It

Rating Averages

My Friends Not rated. () Want To See Not Interested
All Flixster 3.0 Stars (5277) Want To See 5586 Not Interested 21656
Female 2.5 Stars (2910) Want To See 3080 Not Interested 11941
Male 3.0 Stars (2367) Want To See 2506 Not Interested 9715

More Like This

Tip

If you liked this, then you'll also probably like...

Got another recommendation for someone who liked this movie? Add it to the list!

Got an opinion? Use the buttons to vote on all the suggestions people have added.

If lots of people vote, the best suggestions will rise to the top.

The Wicker Man (67%)
They Live (40%)
The Wrong Man (40%)
The Proposition (25%)
The Bourne Ultimatum (19%)

Plot: Harlan (Oscar nominee Edward Norton), a swaggering stranger who's convinced he's a cowboy, looks like a knight in shining armor to a rebellious teen named Tobe (Evan Rachel Wood), a girl who's growing...( read more  read more... ) up fast on the edge of the San Fernando Valley. But are Harlan's delusions strong enough to overpower the grim realities of her life? Rory Culkin, David Morse and Bruce Dern co-star in this modern-day Western with a twist.

Post it anywhere Link it anywhere

My Friends Said...


Recent Reviews


  • 4.0 Stars
    MCT:
    October 31, 2007
    A cerebral romance with wonderful performances from Ed Norton, Evan Rachel Wood, Rory Culkin, & David Morse.
  • 1.5 Stars
    MCT:
    July 6, 2008
    I was dissapointed in this film. It was too extreme in some point to be realistic.
  • 5.0 Stars
    MCT:
    June 13, 2008
    Nortan carries the movie, strong performance form morse too
  • 3.0 Stars
    MCT:
    March 28, 2008
    I'm having trouble thinking of anything I want to say about this movie. I'll give it a shot tomorrow.

    TOMORROW: ...Nope. Still nothing. The movie was more interesting than this - why can't I formulate anything to say about it? I guess Edward Norton is pretty damn good as always but why are his characters always so violent? Also, I didn't know Evan Rachel Wood could act. I thought she was just kind of floating around Hollywood, being pretty.

    Shady ending - especially the last minute or so. As everyone has said, it starts off stronger than it finishes. Norton really sells that love junk in the first act; it's treacle so thick that it could only come from a knight of the Ol' West, and the fact that he can make it work says something about his performance on several levels. You'd know what I mean if you saw it.

    I think we need more movies like this - interesting genre-bending explorations of mental illness - but it would help if they were better.
  • 3.0 Stars
    MCT:
    March 12, 2008
    "Starts as a 10, ends as a 1" is a commonly used quote for this movie... and they're right. For the first 40 minutes or so, it's a masterpiece on psychological indie film with larger-than-life performances by Norton and the great Evan Rachel Wood along with a nice role for a grown-up Rory Culkin... but after a while, it starts going down into a spiral of melodramatic performances and stupid situations (Norton on acid?!)... or was it a surreal film? I never figured it out but it was a disappointment for what looked like a masterpiece to me... lucky for me, Evan
    Rachel Wood will marry me no matter what! :-)
  • 4.5 Stars
    MCT:
    January 1, 2009
    A strange film, seemingly unaware of it's own odd plot. But Norton's character is fascinating, and he plays it extremelly well. I liked this one a lot. Reminiscent a bit of Kill Bill Vol 2.

Comments


  • marcusH
    Just watched it..Was'nt as great as i'd been led to believe but was still very good, not sure about the ending tho..Evan's on top form as usual;D
    posted 623 days ago